How Much is a BULLYMAKE Box?

A BULLYMAKE dog toy subscription typically costs between $29–$45 per month, depending on how long you commit to your subscription. Here’s how it breaks down:

Monthly plans sit on the higher end of the range and provide the most flexibility.

Multi-month plans lower your per-box cost by committing to multiple months

First-time subscriber discounts are often available (always worth checking our site for current promos)

What comes in every BULLYMAKE box?

Each month, we send:

2–3 durable dog toys built specifically for aggressive chewers

3 tasty dog treats — or you can choose a Toys Only box (4-5 tough toys)

A brand-new monthly theme to keep playtime exciting

Price is one of the top questions we get, and for good reason. If your dog destroys toys like it’s their full-time job, price matters.

For aggressive chewers, many dog parents share that the BULLYMAKE box ends up being cheaper than constantly replacing toys one by one from the pet store.

What budget-friendly options exist for power chewer dog subscriptions?

Let’s be honest: truly budget-friendly options for power chewers are hard to find. Many lower-cost dog boxes just aren’t built to survive aggressive chewing. For dogs that destroy toys quickly, “budget-friendly” means not wasting money over and over again.

That’s where we come in. BULLYMAKE is often seen as a more budget-conscious option for power chewer households because we focus on:

Durability first

Customization

Long-term value

What makes our box pricing practical for aggressive chewers is what you get for the cost. High-quality dog toys designed for strong jaws often retail for $20–$25 per toy on their own.

When you’re buying two or three at a time (plus treats), the costs add up fast. Since every BULLYMAKE box includes 2–3 tough toys plus 3 treats (or 4-5 tough toys in our Toys Only box), many dog parents find they’re actually spending less overall.

That value shows up in our customer’s feedback. Some describe BULLYMAKE as having a “reasonable cost,” while others say the subscription helps them “keep track of spending instead of constantly buying new toys.”

A common theme? The toys last longer, which means fewer replacements. Plus, if your dog manages to break a BULLYMAKE toy within 45 days of receiving it, BULLYMAKE will replace it for FREE!

For power chewer dog parents, the most budget-friendly option is often the one that actually holds up. And that’s where a durability-focused subscription like BULLYMAKE can save money over time.

★★★★★ "Great for all dogs!" My staffy and mini fox terrier absolutely love the toys they received. Worth the price and great quality. - Shaye Brooks

How Does BULLYMAKE Pricing Compare to Replacing Destroyed Toys?

High-durability dog toys typically cost $20-$25 per toy, and power chewer households often go through multiple toys each month. When you factor in replacing two or three toys at a time plus treats or enrichment items, the cost can add up quickly.

A BULLYMAKE box on the other hand, costs $29–$45 per month and includes 2–3 toys designed specifically for aggressive chewers, plus treats or a Toys Only option with 4-5 tough dog toys.

For many dog parents, that means a predictable monthly cost instead of surprise toy runs and impulse purchases. Instead of spending money repeatedly on toys that fail, a durability-focused subscription helps shift the cost toward toys built to hold up longer.

Over time, this can reduce both overall spending and the frustration of always needing replacements. Don’t believe us? Check out these reviews!

Can You Customize BULLYMAKE to Fit Your Budget?

Yes, BULLYMAKE offers several ways to customize your box so it fits both your dog’s needs and your budget. With plans starting at $29 per month, BULLYMAKE is customizable for power-chewer households. You can:

Choose toy types that match how your dog’s chew strength and play style

Opt for longer subscription plans to lower the per-box cost

Adjust delivery frequency to spread out spending over time

That way, you’re not paying for toys or treats your dog won’t use. For aggressive chewers, budget-friendly usually means predictable costs and fewer replacements, and BULLYMAKE customization makes that possible.

What Are the Top Features of a Premium Dog Subscription for Aggressive Chewers?

A premium dog subscription for strong chewers is all about durability, variety, and convenience. For dogs that destroy standard toys, the right features can make a real difference in safety, engagement and long-term value.

Here’s what we build into every BULLYMAKE box:

Exclusive, High-Quality Toys Built for Strong Jaws

Premium subscriptions focus on toys designed specifically for aggressive and power chewers, not generic toys repurposed for a box.

BULLYMAKE toys are made from tough materials like nylon, reinforced rubber, ballistic fabric, and heavy-duty rope to stand up to serious chewing.

A Variety of Toy Types to Prevent Boredom

Strong chewers still get bored. A premium box offers a balanced mix of toy types, including:

Nylon for long-lasting gnawing

Rubber for bouncing, stuffing, and freezing

Rope for tug-of-war and interactive play

Ballistic toys for tearing, tossing, and carrying

Plush options for light play and satisfying destructive desires

This variety keeps dogs mentally stimulated and redirects destructive behavior.

Dual-Purpose Toys for Extra Enrichment

Many premium toys are designed to do more than one job. Nylon toys can be spread with soft treats, rubber toys can be stuffed or frozen, and ballistic toys can satisfy both tearing and snuggling instincts.

This layered enrichment helps dogs stay engaged longer.

Built-In Toy Rotation

Monthly deliveries naturally rotate toys in and out of your dog’s routine, keeping playtime fresh without you having to think about it.

Toy rotation is especially important for strong, intelligent chewers who lose interest in the same toy quickly.

Replacement Guarantee for Tough Toys

One key feature of a premium subscription is peace of mind. If a dog destroys one of BULLYMAKE’s toughest toys, it’s backed by a replacement guarantee. That adds real value for power chewer households.

Convenience That Saves Time and Effort

A premium subscription eliminates the constant cycle of searching for new toys or making extra store trips. Toys and treats arrive automatically, so your dog always has something new and engaging to play with.

Treats Dogs Actually Love

Lastly, premium subscriptions include high-quality treats that dogs get excited about. For many households, the treats become just as anticipated as the toys.

Is a BULLYMAKE Box Worth It for Aggressive Chewers?

Based on customer feedback and an average 4.4 star rating from more than 1600 reviews on Trustpilot, many dog owners say that a BULLYMAKE dog subscription box is worth it for their aggressive chewers.

The feedback we hear most often?

Toys last longer than expected

Dogs stay engaged and excited for each box

Fewer trips to the store to replace destroyed toys

Many customers tell us BULLYMAKE is one of the few subscriptions that truly caters to aggressive chewers, not just dogs who nibble politely.

The replacement guarantee and customer service also come up again and again as reasons people stick with us.

With thousands of happy customers and strong third-party ratings, a BULLYMAKE box is widely viewed as a worthwhile investment for dogs that routinely destroy ordinary toys.

Is BULLYMAKE a Good Gift?

Yes, a BULLYMAKE box is one of the best gifts for dogs, especially for pups that love to chew and owners who are tired of replacing destroyed toys.

Instead of a single toy that may or may not last, a subscription delivers ongoing excitement. Every month brings a new theme, new toys, and new challenges for dogs who love to chew.

We also offer shorter-term plans, making it easy to gift a box for a month or three, perfect for birthdays, new puppies, or “just because.”

Holiday and seasonal themes add even more fun! From festive designs to limited-edition toys, themed boxes make each delivery feel special for dogs and the people who love watching them tear into the box.

If you’re looking for a gift that’s practical, exciting, and built to last, a BULLYMAKE box checks all the boxes for dogs who play hard and chew harder.

So, Is a BULLYMAKE Box Worth It?

For dogs that destroy ordinary toys in minutes, a durability-first subscription can help turn unpredictable dog enrichment into a consistent monthly cost.

If you’re tired of broken toys, emergency store runs, and wasting money on enrichment that doesn’t last, a BULLYMAKE box may be the smarter long-term choice.

Ready to see what’s inside this month’s box? Start your BULLYMAKE subscription today and give your best bud something to chew on.